The rocky road to forensic credibility in Texas leads to positive results

Image result for texas flag

This story from the Texas Monthly continues to be a testament to how opening the minds of diverse forensic and legal professionals can lead to progress in reaching scientific goals and standards in the courts. Here is a excerpt about happenings when the Texas Forensic Science Commission started getting past its rancorous 2005 beginnings.

“Defense lawyers saw that lab analysts weren’t purposefully sending innocent people to prison; they were skilled but overworked scientists. Prosecutors saw that defense lawyers weren’t crazed conspiracy nuts; they were spirited advocates for their clients. The next roundtable was co-hosted with the Court of Criminal Appeals’ Criminal Justice Integrity Unit, a similarly collaborative commission put together by Judge Barbara Hervey, in 2008. The groups made two strong recommendations: first, develop a plan for certifying, or licensing, all state forensic examiners by an independent body. Second, come up with a process for notifying everyone affected by forensic errors—prosecutors, defense attorneys, defendants, and the courts themselves. They also began co-hosting seminars on forensic science, where they talked about everything from arson developments to new designer drugs.”

http://www.texasmonthly.com/articles/false-impressions/#sthash.ZBlGmWJJ.dpuf

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Get off your liberal duff and donate to the Innocence Projects – 336 exonerations to date

Innocence Project

Learn about the reasons wrongful convictions occur in the US. Its not what you may think.

Retired police chief Darrel Stephens has something to say about the subject:

Through my work for the Innocence Inquiry Commission and later the Innocence Project, I came to understand the challenges and contributing causes of wrongful convictions. As a former police chief I did a lot of work promoting best practices for eyewitness identification and evidence preservation, encouraging police departments across the country to adopt policies that help avoid wrongful convictions.

Donate for Justice The New York Innocence Project

Michael Hanline was exonerated in 2015. Justin Brooks and Alex Simpson led the CIP litigation team.

Donate to Sponsor an Innocent Individual The California Innocence Project. Free the #CA12

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | 3 Comments

Forensics: Cross exam of a crime lab DNA tech gets high marks for drama

This case has some excellent insight into how a defense attorney finds a crack in a lab tech’s QA protocols [ she spit on a DNA sample] and then tries to blow up all the other work-product used by the Prosecution.

The evidence of interest is a single bullet with arguable DNA recovered from the scene 4 months AFTER the crime. Ooops.

The def attorney also uses a phone message from a cop to the crime lab gal.

From the news article: “The message, Buting [the defense attorney]  pointed out, asked Culhane [the lab tech] to test evidence “to try to put” Halbach [the homicide victim]  in Avery’s [the bad guy] trailer or garage.”  Ooops.

http://www.jsonline.com/news/crime/dna-experts-record-ripped-b99643010z1-363819471.html

Posted in AAFS | Tagged , , , , | 1 Comment

Tx Forensic Sci Commission gets kudos for driving bitemark analysts to ground

Forensics-Opener

Well, its not just the bitemarker zealots being scoured by the Tx Commission as mentioned in the January issue of Texas Monthly. But, its title is “False Impressions” and its headpiece image is the above closeup of some badly busted up dental models.

The article runs the details of this non-regulatory panel’s rise to new prominence in Criminal Justice news for its stance on junk arson investigations, DNA and the pesky 4 remaining bitemark dentists bold enough to showup at the TCFSC proceedings to defend themselves.

The defending dentists totally missed (intentionally of course) the Commission’s oft-published charge to them to present legitimate scientific data behind their belief-based “system” of dental identification. This Texas article gives them short-shrift.

The are numerous quotes from the panel and one outstanding member, general counsel Lynn Garcia, who at the outset of the Commission’s bitemark journey, took alot of objectionable flack from the very same dental bunch described in the article.

Thanks to http://gritsforbreakfast@gmail.com

Posted in AAFS, ABFO, Bite Marks, Bitemarks | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Outspoken Innocence Project detractor runs pricey Forensic Science ethics training course

Wrongful convictions and almost daily news reports of exonerations have spurred a new industry in forensic science. These events have created a new theme in forensic science, namely “forensic science reform,” where government agencies, CJ institutes, academia and private parties have amplified their focus onto ethics and anti “cognitive bias” training in varied curricula. A curious outlier within all this education includes John A. Collins.

A pre-paid PR notice on Collin’s offerings regarding forensic ethics training just came out here. Connected to this is his business of forensic training here, which leads to the plethora of courses Collins offers to LE and crime lab folks for a pretty penny.

Collins is a multi-credentialed ex-crime lab director who has become rather notorious in the hard-core police crime lab community as an out spoken self-published debunker of wrongful convictions litigators and Criminal Justice meta-data analysts like the Innocence Projects and the National Registry of Exonerations. A closer look at his opinions are reflected here.

I’m reluctant to express much more than confusion regarding this confluence of Collin’s recent PR blast and his past public statements considering forensic science, in its practice, as being “nearly flawless.”

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Forensic Research: Necrobiomes from Body Farm experiment

"black and white bacteria closeup"

A mini study makes researchers optimistic about body fluids and such.

http://www.regaltribune.com/necrobiomes-and-their-effects-on-forensic-science/24464/

Posted in AAFS, CSI | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Forensic Anthro in Central Park

Forensic Dig is No Mere Walk in the Park

Professor Angelique Corthals of the Department of Sciences set up a crime scene in the composting area of the park near the 102nd street entrance after receiving a permit from the Central Park Conservancy to perform the exercise. “The permit process took a few months. I wanted to make sure we could perform it without damaging any of the landscaping of Central Park,” said Corthals. “The composting facility was a perfect place to organize this, as it is not landscaped and it’s vast enough to hide a body.”

http://www.jjay.cuny.edu/news/forensic-dig-no-mere-walk-park

Posted in AAFS, Crime, missing persons | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Forensic Medicine Used to Convict for Moral Crimes In Tunisia

Junk forensic science and its misuse in criminal proceedings occurs wherever human rights and fairness are absent.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Missouri Forensic Science program is told they can help prevent wrongful convictions

“I’m not here to bash the judicial system,” Barry Beach ( over 30 years in prison ) told a forensic science class at the University of Montana on Friday. “I’m here to say, ‘Let’s do what we can to make it better.’

Someone should educate them about ethics problems with police and prosecutors as well. No offense meant. A few unscrupulous people exist in all walks of life.

http://missoulian.com/news/local/beach-tells-um-forensic-science-students-they-can-prevent-wrongful/article_357235e3-632e-5978-93c4-fc1987fa9286.html

Posted in AAFS | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Crime lab event collects missing girl’s family’s DNA. Body later ID’d.

The identification was made based on DNA samples given from family members at the Attorney General’s event to raise awareness for and help loved ones locate missing persons, Never Forgotten: Arkansas Takes Action.

http://txktoday.com/news/never-forgotten-event-helps-identify-missing-persons-remains/

Posted in DNA profiling, missing persons | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment